History Mysteries

Does this building look familiar? Not only does it still stand today, but it’s very much in use, as busy as ever. While the surroundings have clearly changed, you may recognize its distinctive shape and small size.

Here’s a look back at one of Wellesley’s oldest churches. It’s changed a great deal over the years! Any guesses as to which it is?

This image depicts the former Elm Park Hotel, c.1903-1908 at the intersection of Washington Street and Worcester Road in Wellesley Hills. This triangular plot of land is now Elm Park and home to the Isaac Sprague Memorial Tower. Note the ornate, cast-iron object that is prominently pictured in the center foreground of this photograph; any ideas on what this is?

Any idea where these children are headed in Wellesley, or what they have in common?

The above picture shows past generations enjoying a summer day at the beach on Morse’s Pond. The land was purchased by the town in 1931 and opened as a beach in 1935. Does anyone know what purpose the pond served before it was the popular town landmark it is today?

This image is from an 1897 Wellesley atlas found in our Maps & Plans Collection. Note the triangular section of land at the corner of Central St. and Blossom St. Can anyone guess what this controversial plot of land is called today? Extra credit if you know what name Blossom St. is known by today!

These Wellesley fire men are pictured in front of the old Church Street Station, c.1912. They are proudly posing in Wellesley’s first motorized fire engine. Even though the picture is in black & white, you probably envision the fire engine painted a classic red, but according to contemporary Townsman newspaper articles it was painted a different color! Any ideas on what color Wellesley’s first motorized fire engine was painted?

On the Halloween evening of October 31, 1900, the bell of the Wellesley Congregational Church, also known as the Village Church, began to toll without a soul in sight! Deacons, policemen and residents rushed to the scene but found the church in darkness and no one pulling the rope to the bell; however, the bell continued to toll through the evening! Any ideas on how this spooky mystery was solved?

The annual Wellesley-Needham football game began in 1882 at Hunnewell Park, now known as Morton Field, with Wellesley emerging as the winner with a score of 4-0. Football uniforms and equipment were scarce or nonexistent in the early days and the image above depicts the Wellesley High School team of 1901-1902 with an unusual piece of equipment hanging from the necks of several players (circled). Any ideas on what this piece of football equipment was called and what part of the body it protected?

The Christmas card pictured above is from the collection of the Wellesley Historical Society and dates from c. 1920–1930. It was donated by the Fleming family as part of a significant collection of greeting cards. Christmas cards usually bring to mind religious images such as the Nativity or more secular scenes like snowmen and snow-covered landscapes. So what is a sailing ship doing on a Christmas card?

Do you recognize this Wellesley resident and her magnificent sculpture?

Consider how early residents of Wellesley kept their houses comfortable in the winter 100 years ago. Many would have heated their homes with a coal-fired boiler or furnace. Coal was an important source of energy at the turn of the twentieth century, not just for home heating, but also for industry and transportation. The image above shows a coal yard at a long-lived Wellesley business – can you name this company or its location?

Recognize this wintry Wellesley scene? Painted by Wellesley artist Elizabeth Huntington (1913–2001) in 1942, this image shows a popular intersection in town. Do you know its location?

The buildings pictured above were once part of a religious school in Wellesley. The buildings on the right no longer exist, but the building on the left has been enlarged and is now part of a college campus in Wellesley. Can you guess which college this building belongs to and what religious organization it once served?

The building above was located on Central Street in Wellesley, Massachusetts. Does anyone know exactly where it was located and what it was used for?

Wellesley High School graduates, class of 1897, in front of Wellesley High School.

The students seen here are seated in front of Wellesley’s first dedicated high school, built in 1893. Only in use as a high school until 1907, this building still exists today and has been repurposed over the years. Can you guess which building this is and its current use? Bonus points if you can identify the principal seen in profile!

Mica Lane is a narrow street located off of Washington Street in Wellesley Lower Falls. Have you ever wondered how Mica Lane got its name?

These jail cells were used in Wellesley in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries and were known as the “lockup.” Does anybody know where they were located? Hint – they were not located at the police station.

Do you remember this man and the famous fare he served? Do you know which current local hotspot is this locale’s successor?

Upham Elementary School opened its doors to students on January 2, 1957. The school was dedicated in June 1957 and named in memory of the late Ernest F. Upham. Mr. Upham served as the head of the History Department at Wellesley High School and died on February 9, 1957, the same year the elementary school opened. Prior to the school’s dedication to Ernest Upham, the school went by another name. Do you know the original name of Upham School?

Does this railroad station look familiar? Wellesley was fortunate enough to have several stops on the Boston & Worcester line (later renamed the Boston & Albany line) which now serves as the MBTA commuter rail. Can you guess if this historical image is of the Wellesley Farms, Wellesley Hills, or Wellesley Square stop? Bonus points if you can explain why the Christmas greetings are written on the front of the postcard instead of the back!

Do cold winter days make you want to sit down with a hot cup of tea? If so, you are in good company! Wellesley has been home to many tea rooms over the years, from stand-alone tea shops, to restaurants, to on-campus college establishments. In the 1920s, Wellesley tea shops often had whimsical names including The Bird Cage, The Blue Dragon, The Green Bough and The Oriole. The picture above depicts one of these creatively named tea rooms located in Wellesley Square– can you guess which one it is?

While we all remember digging out after multiple storms in February 2015 and during the Blizzard of 1978, there is one more February that produced record amounts of snow for the Town of Wellesley. In fact, there were so many snow days that February in Wellesley that April vacation was canceled for students! Do you recall the year that this record February snowfall happened?

One road in Wellesley, Garden Road, is aptly named for the spring season. Do you know how this street got its name and when it first appeared on maps in Wellesley?

Solomon Flagg III (1804-1892) was a longtime Wellesley resident in the 19th century and was well-known for his outstanding record of community service in the town. At various times, he held the positions of Town Clerk and Justice of the Peace, and served on the school committee for over 25 years. However, he also filled the post of Thythingman, Sealer of Bread, and Hogreave. While they may not be town offices today, they were common in the 1800s. What is a Thythingman?

Have you ever noticed this bench in Wellesley Square near the Post Office? Who is Bernie Zetlan and why was he known as the “Harmonica Man?”

The Wellesley Hills Market at 251 Washington Street was a fixture in Wellesley for over fifty years, opening in 1925 and closing in 1982. The image above shows the market in 1959, when a pound of coffee cost only 59 cents. This building was originally a home and was constructed before the market moved in. Can you guess which century this house was built in?

Have you ever noticed this formation of stone at the intersection of Grove Street and Dover Road in Wellesley? At first glance, it appears to be an interesting geological formation, but a plaque at the site deems it “Problem Rock.” This begs the question – what is the problem with Problem Rock?

The Wellesley Historical Society is delighted to collaborate on this month’s History Mystery with the Unitarian Universalist Society of Wellesley Hills.  This post is written by UU member and history buff, Marc Shechtman. Photo courtesy of the Unitarian Universalist Society of Wellesley Hills and shows the church c.1930

In 2006, the Israeli Holocaust Memorial, Yad Vasehem, honored two Wellesley citizens as “Righteous Among the Nations,” an award granted to “honor non-Jews who risked their lives, liberty or position to save Jews during the Holocaust.” Of the nearly 25,000 documented heroes who have been honored since the award was established in 1963, only five Americans have been declared such heroes, and two of them are from Wellesley!  Do you know the story behind our true local heroes?

Every October, Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) celebrates Ether Day. On this day, a Wellesley resident is recognized as being the first person to publicly demonstrate the use of ether for anesthesia during surgery at MGH on October 16, 1846. This person lived in the home pictured above, appropriately named “Etherton Cottage.” Do you know the name of this noted Wellesley resident?

A quick look at this Victorian greeting card from our collection and you might assume that it was designed for a spring holiday or special occasion. But take a closer look and you’ll see that it is actually a Christmas card! Many Christmas cards from the 1880s in our collection feature a spring theme with various flowers. Check out the answer below to find out more about these flower-inspired Christmas cards.

If you lived in Wellesley in the first half of the twentieth century, this building was an important part of the Abbott Road streetscape. Originally the old Bemis Estate, this building was purchased and used by a Wellesley club for over 50 years before it burned down in 1953. Does anybody know what club was housed in this elegant building? Hint: that club is still active today!

Wellesley has utilized many buildings at various locations to house its high school students over the years. The building shown above was the High School from 1907-1938. Do you know where it was located? Hint: it was located on the site of one of Wellesley’s current schools.